If you prefer listening, check out our AI-powered podcast:
Table of contents:
Procurement plays a vital role in any small to medium-sized business. Ensuring that you have the right materials and services in place at the right time, and at the right cost, can significantly impact your bottom line. However, understanding the right procurement model to adopt can be challenging. Should you focus on driving down costs, or is building relationships with suppliers more important? What role does inventory strategy play?
In this post, we’ll guide you through various procurement strategies like the Push-Pull Inventory Strategy, Porter’s Generic Strategies, the Boston Box, and more. Each model offers practical insights to streamline your procurement process, improve supplier relationships, and optimize resource allocation, all while ensuring your business stays competitive and agile.
Push-Pull Inventory Strategy: Balancing Demand and Supply
The Push-Pull Inventory Strategy helps businesses determine whether to "push" inventory into the market based on forecasted demand or "pull" inventory as needed based on real customer demand. Small businesses often face the challenge of managing inventory efficiently without tying up too much capital.
Tip for Push-Pull Strategy
If you're dealing with seasonal products or fluctuating demand, a pull strategy may be more appropriate. This will allow you to order stock based on actual customer purchases, reducing excess inventory. For products with steady demand, a push strategy can ensure you're always prepared and minimize stockouts.
Example
A small e-commerce business might use a pull strategy for high-end, low-demand items (like custom electronics), only placing orders when customers purchase the item. However, for frequently sold items (like phone accessories), they might use a push system to maintain a constant stock.
Porter’s Generic Strategies in Procurement
Porter’s Generic Strategies outline three primary ways to gain a competitive edge: Cost Leadership, Differentiation, and Focus. These strategies can be applied to procurement to help you either minimize costs, distinguish your supply chain, or focus on niche markets.
Tips for Porter’s Generic Strategies
Cost Leadership: Look for bulk purchasing opportunities or low-cost suppliers, but maintain product quality. For example, opting for international suppliers where raw materials are cheaper can help you stay competitive.
Differentiation: Focus on building strong relationships with high-quality suppliers to ensure your product offering is superior to competitors.
Focus: If your business operates in a niche market, consider specialized suppliers who can meet your unique needs.
Example
A small company producing organic skincare might use differentiation to source eco-friendly, premium-quality ingredients, differentiating their product from cheaper alternatives in the market.
Boston Box: Allocating Resources in Procurement
The Boston Box (also known as the BCG Matrix) helps businesses allocate resources effectively across different product lines. For procurement, it helps identify which suppliers or products deserve more attention and which ones might need re-evaluation.
Tips for Boston Box in Procurement
Stars: Products with high market growth and high market share should have reliable, high-quality suppliers.
Cash Cows: For mature products with high market share, focus on cost-effective procurement to maintain profitability.
Problem Children: New, untested products might require you to invest in flexible or short-term supplier contracts to limit risks.
Dogs: Consider phasing out suppliers associated with products in low-growth markets.
Example
A growing tech company might treat its best-selling product components as "Stars," ensuring top-tier suppliers, while treating slow-moving items as "Dogs," reducing investment in those supply chains.
SWOT Analysis: Assessing Procurement Strengths and Weaknesses
The SWOT Analysis—which stands for Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats—is an essential tool for evaluating your procurement operations. It helps identify areas where you can improve supplier management, cut costs, and mitigate risks.
Tips for Using SWOT in Procurement
Strengths: Identify key advantages in your current procurement strategy, such as strong supplier relationships or bulk purchasing agreements.
Weaknesses: Recognize any inefficiencies in your procurement process, like long lead times or high costs.
Opportunities: Explore potential areas for growth, such as new suppliers or technologies that can improve procurement efficiency.
Threats: Be aware of external risks, such as fluctuating supplier prices or global supply chain disruptions.
Example
A small electronics company might discover that its reliance on a single supplier (a weakness) puts it at risk of price hikes (a threat). By diversifying its supplier base, it can create more opportunities for cost savings.
PESTEL: Analysing External Procurement Factors
PESTEL stands for Political, Economic, Socio-cultural, Technological, Environmental, and Legal factors. This model is used to analyse the external environment that affects procurement. It’s especially useful in navigating global supply chains or when sourcing from multiple countries.
Tips for PESTEL in Procurement
Political: Be aware of international trade policies or tariffs that could affect supplier costs.
Economic: Monitor exchange rates and inflation trends, which may impact the cost of foreign suppliers.
Socio-cultural: Ensure suppliers align with your company’s values, such as sustainability or fair labor practices.
Technological: Take advantage of procurement software or automation tools to streamline purchasing processes.
Environmental: Source from suppliers who adhere to environmentally sustainable practices.
Legal: Stay updated on changes in import/export regulations or compliance standards for your industry.
Example
A food distributor sourcing products from overseas might have to consider both political tariffs and environmental regulations, impacting which suppliers they choose.
Sourcing Gemstone: Choosing the Best Sourcing Approach
The Sourcing Gemstone model provides a framework for deciding how to source materials or services. It includes six strategies: volume concentration, best-price evaluation, global sourcing, product specification improvement, joint process improvement, and relationship restructuring.
Tip for Sourcing Gemstone
For small to medium-sized companies, focusing on volume concentration can provide the best savings. Consolidating your purchases with fewer suppliers can give you negotiating power to lower costs. On the other hand, if you’re looking for long-term relationships, consider joint process improvements, where you work with suppliers to refine processes and reduce costs together.
Example
A small manufacturing company consolidating all its office supply purchases to a single vendor can negotiate a bulk discount, helping reduce overhead. Alternatively, if you rely heavily on a key supplier for raw materials, working together to improve delivery times can enhance your overall production process.
Porter’s Five Forces: Understanding Market Dynamics in Procurement
Porter’s Five Forces is typically used to assess competition but can also guide procurement strategy. By understanding supplier power, the threat of substitutes, and the level of rivalry among existing players, you can make more informed sourcing decisions.
Tip for Porter’s Five Forces
If your suppliers hold significant bargaining power, you could face price hikes or long delivery times. In this case, diversifying your supplier base could be beneficial. Keep an eye on substitute products too—if an alternative material or service could do the job just as well, you might have more negotiating leverage.
Example
A local bakery sourcing flour might realize they are heavily dependent on a single supplier. To mitigate risk, they could seek out alternate suppliers or explore substitutes like locally grown grains, which may even resonate better with customers who prefer sustainable, locally sourced products.
Ansoff Matrix: Exploring New Procurement Opportunities
The Ansoff Matrix helps businesses explore strategies for growth through market penetration, product development, market development, or diversification. In procurement, this model can help you assess whether to stick with existing suppliers and products or explore new markets and materials.
Practical Tip for Ansoff Matrix
If you’re looking to grow your business, consider diversifying your supplier base. Expanding into new geographical markets for sourcing, or developing new product lines that require innovative materials, can both be effective strategies. Always evaluate the risks associated with new suppliers or products before making a change.
Example
A small clothing brand might start sourcing eco-friendly fabrics to align with current market trends. By working with suppliers in a new geographical region, they can introduce an entirely new product line and potentially tap into a broader customer base.
Wrap up
Adopting the right procurement models is essential for optimizing operations, managing suppliers, and positioning your business for success. The Push-Pull Inventory Strategy helps with efficient stock management, while Porter’s Generic Strategies guide cost reduction or supplier differentiation. The Boston Box offers a clear framework for resource allocation, and tools like SWOT and PESTEL analyses ensure you account for internal and external factors that affect procurement decisions. Finally, models such as Sourcing Gemstone and Ansoff Matrix provide valuable approaches for growth and supply chain improvements.
Whether you're looking to streamline supplier relationships or expand into new markets, these procurement models will provide the structure you need to make informed, effective decisions.
Ready to elevate your procurement strategy? Start by assessing your current procurement process through a SWOT analysis or explore new sourcing opportunities with the Sourcing Gemstone model. For personalized support in choosing the right procurement model for your business, contact us today. We’re here to help you streamline operations and drive sustainable growth.
Comments